Schweizerische Gesellschaft für Strahlenbiologie und Medizinische Physik
Société Suisse de Radiobiologie et de Physique Médicale
Società Svizzera di Radiobiologia e di Fisica Medica
Swiss Society of Radiobiology and Medical Physics

Bulletin 1/2000 (April 2000)
Bulletin 1/00

----------

Varian-Preis

Lage und Zukunft

WG SCBI

Optimization and Individualization

Winterschule in Pichl

Stellenmarkt

Tagungskalender

Vorstand SGSMP
(Adressen)

----------

andere Bulletins / d'autres bulletins / altri bolletini / other bulletins


"Optimization and Individualization of Radiotherapy "

a proposal for a National Centers of Competence in Research (NCCR) project by the
Scientific Association of Swiss Radiation Oncology (SASRO)

Introduction

In the SGSMP Bulletin 1/99 you have been informed that the SASRO has written a notice of intent for a NCCR proposal.
The idea to apply for an NCCR grant was the result of discussions within the SASRO "basic and translational research group" and with the SASRO executive board. During 1999 meetings were held in various groups of SASRO and SGSMP to come up with a preproposal by end of July 1999. The SASRO network should be the backbone of a collaboration to strengthen the position of radiation oncology in Switzerland over the next five to ten years. It was clearly realized that the chances were modest. It was decided that it was nevertheless worth to try it. In case we were not successful in the first run a second chance would come up approx. two or three years later and the ideas worked out could also be the base for scientific proposals to the Swiss National Science Foundation or to the Swiss Cancer League. The hope was however to succeed with the NCCR and to get substantial resources to support a network of research thereby improving radiation oncology to the benefit of the patients.

Main research topics

The following should remind you of the main ideas and of the reasoning:
Ionizing radiation is the most important single agent for cancer treatment. Between one third and one fourth of the Swiss population will suffer from cancer during their life-time, and over 50% of these will be treated by radiation oncologists i.e. about 15'000 patients each year in 20 registered radiation oncology centers. Important steps have been made towards better treatment modalities and safer applications, mainly as a consequence of better target/tumor definition, high precision of treatment delivery, different modalities of therapy (photons, protons, electrons, brachytherapy) and use of refined prognostic factors tailored to cancer therapy according to the aggressive behavior of the individual neoplasm. Furthermore, the rapid evolution in the field of biology and computer technology relevant to clinical radio-oncology (molecular biology and radiophysics) is expected to lead to a significant increase in cured cancer patients in the next decade, and to a considerable improvement in quality of life for most patients. The key part in this potential improvement will be individualized treatment on the basis of a promotion and coordination of research from basic principles to controlled clinical studies as outlined in this proposal.
New developments in beam delivery, treatment planning, and patient positioning are necessary prerequisites for precision radiotherapy. The important contributions of Swiss radio-oncology departments to 3-D-dose planning, intensity modulated irradiation techniques, stereotactic photon radiotherapy; and its leading position in the development of dynamic proton beam delivery at PSI, with the World's first compact gantry, are essential for investigating state-of-the-art radiation treatments. Switzerland is, therefore, ideally equipped for optimizing and comparing combined radiation modalities on a theoretical basis and in clinical trials.
Image fusion will be developed using CT, MRI, PET, SPECT, and biological imaging, for a more precise and specific treatment planning. Computer-aided positioning systems are needed to increase precision, reduce setup time, and monitor patient movement during treatment. Real time tracking of tumors moving inside the patient’s body with feedback to the irradiation delivery will be developed. Verification of the dose distribution (including quality control) for the individualized 3-D dose treatment is a major goal of the proposal.
Radiobiology is a basic research discipline to establish novel treatment modalities. By meticulous research over 50 years, a mathematical relationship was established between biologic tumor response, damage to normal tissues, and specific doses of ionizing radiation delivered to defined tumor systems. DNA has been considered the primary target of radiotherapy for many decades. Research in molecular biology has now identified multiple other intra- and extranuclear, as well as extracellular, cytotoxic targets of ionizing radiation. The expected cancer cell changes induced by ionizing radiation will be exploited to design novel biological or chemical radiomodifiers. Blood vessels of tumors and of normal organs, and the process of their formation (angiogenesis), are targets of primary importance with regard to both antineoplastic effects and radiation toxicity. Both basic and clinical research will be further exploited in collaboration with basic research institutions and the pharmaceutical industry in Switzerland. A structured coordination would establish a direct link to patient treatment and ensure a more rapid completion of adequate preclinical tests and a faster translation of validated research results into clinical applications. In particular, we expect marked increases in therapeutic ratio, i.e. achievement of tumor-cell specific cytotoxicity with no increment in damage to normal tissues. These methods will be tested and validated both in vitro and in vivo leading to clinical trials. In parallel, specific molecular radiobiological characterization for normal and neoplastic cells and tissues will be used as a basis for individualized treatment.
Improvements in the field of tumor identification, tumor extension and tumor localization as well as the detection of novel prognostic factors or molecular radiosensitizers will be implemented in clinical radiotherapy.
A multidisciplinary task force sets priorities and will decide when clinical studies will be started. With the existing and continuously improved quality assurance of therapy, patient treatment results will lead the way to further improvements in tumor control and ultimately in survival.
The NCCR will enable SASRO to efficiently develop and test new strategies in cancer management on the basis of radiation oncology. Because all the Swiss radio-oncological centers are participating in SASRO, we can recruit the critical numbers of cancer patients necessary for statistically significant results.
The diagram below gives a schematic description of the work modules and their relationship.

 

Evaluation / result

The proposal was refereed by two international experts which gave the proposal very good scores, one described even the overall rating as "highest enthusiasm"
In the following judgement the SNSF criticized several aspects of the proposal and was skeptical on the strategic impact. The recommendation was therefore not to write a full proposal and gave little chance of approval this time.

Outlook

The encouraging scores of the scientific experts urge us to make use of the existing potential. In biology two areas are identified which should be pursued, vascularization and its relevance for radiation oncology and improvement of treatment modalities by use of the rapidly evolving progress in molecular, cellular and animal biology including design of novel radiosensitizers.
In medical physics there are also a number of research areas, which could be best exploited in working groups, possibly also leading to grant applications. Treatment plan comparison for irradiation techniques as IMRT for photons and protons, quality assurance are just some of them.

The basic and translational research group of SASRO will organize follow-up meetings with the colleagues, which were involved in the planning of the NCCR. New members are also welcome. The goal of the first meeting will be to structure the activities. The physics working group could well be organized by SGSMP.

Hans Blattmann, coordinator of the SASRO basic and translational group.

top of page Diese Seite wird von Wolf Seelentag betreut (Bulletin-Redaktoren : Roman Menz und Werner Roser), letzte Bearbeitung 16 Juli 2010.
Senden Sie Kommentare und/oder Ergänzungen bitte an den Webmaster SGSMP.